Dhule imperative
The Indian Express Posted online: Thu Jan 31 2013
With fresh evidence exposing
the excessive tactics adopted by the local police in an incident earlier
this month in the Maharashtrian town of Dhule, the state government
needs to demonstrate its capacity to come to grips with the aftermath.
On January 6, there occurred a spat over the settlement of a bill at a
roadside eatery, which in no time took on the dimensions of a communal
clash, leaving six persons, all of them Muslim, dead in police firing.
That what appeared to be a rather unremarkable argument could claim such
a toll is alarming enough and draws attention to the dangers of not
addressing communal faultlines of the sort that appear to have defined
Dhule, especially after riots in 2008. However, the stark picture that
has now emerged — through video footage accessed by this paper —
indicates much more than just incompetence in dealing with an
altercation. It calls into question the police’s conduct.
The footage shows police personnel going on a rampage to destroy
private property and loot shops, and yet more chillingly, to defy the
manual and shoot above the waist at persons in the crowd. With this
sharpening picture of the police allegedly abdicating the basic rules of
professional and impartial conduct, Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan
does not have the luxury of allowing the rhythms of routine inquiries to
run their course before seizing the situation. He needs to urgently act
on the emerging evidence of deliberate police aggression. In fact, the
record suggests that a fair stock-taking will, of necessity, have to be
anchored from outside the town. Reportedly, a chargesheet filed in the
2008 riots by the Dhule police had claimed as an established fact that
Muslims were the masterminds behind all terrorist activities across
India. It would be irresponsible to cast a communal colour on the police
action without a thorough scrutiny — but when the identity of those
felled in police action, in the street version of events, is not seen to
be entirely incidental, there lie the makings of an administrative
crisis that could spiral out of control.
Dhule town is strategically located on the cusp of two national highways, and its location facilitates the hinterland’s access to wider markets. Muslims make up a quarter of the population. And in the textile industry it has historically thrived on, Dhule speaks of an older inclusiveness, having provided a base for north Indians fleeing the upheaval after the 1857 uprising. The dangers obvious in such a town being torn apart by the suspicion of police mal-intent can only be addressed by reassurance through swift government action.
Dhule town is strategically located on the cusp of two national highways, and its location facilitates the hinterland’s access to wider markets. Muslims make up a quarter of the population. And in the textile industry it has historically thrived on, Dhule speaks of an older inclusiveness, having provided a base for north Indians fleeing the upheaval after the 1857 uprising. The dangers obvious in such a town being torn apart by the suspicion of police mal-intent can only be addressed by reassurance through swift government action.
