India: [Shove it Sena at work] Creed of violence - Editorial in DNA

Daily News and Analysis

dnaEdit: Creed of violence
Thursday, 24 July 2014


For the Shiv Sena, which entered the political limelight with a unique brand of divisive and violent politics, nothing has changed

Any defence of, or silence on, the actions of Shiv Sena MP Rajan Vichare who force-fed a catering manager, a Muslim undertaking the Ramzan fast, despite the latter’s protestations, and of the ten other Shiv Sena MPs who allegedly vandalised the New Maharashtra Sadan in protest against not being served Maharashtrian food is untenable. Arshad Zubair, in his complaint to his employer, IRCTC, has categorically stated that the MPs knew his religious persuasion and would have seen the nameplate on his shirt. Leaked video footage of the attack also shows the young man pleading with Vichare to desist from stuffing the food into his mouth. The government’s silence for hours after reports surfaced of this unacceptable acts of MPs, who owe it their allegiance, is unfortunate. Even political compulsions offer no justification for such reluctance to condemn this ghastly act. But none of this should deter Lok Sabha speaker Sumitra Mahajan from adopting a tough line and safeguard Parliament’s prestige. Their suspension from Parliament is the sine qua non before any credible inquiry can be undertaken by a parliamentary panel or the police.

Instead of an outright apology, Shiv Sena supremo Uddhav Thackeray appears to be defending his MPs by saying there was no intention to hurt anyone’s religious sentiments. Vichare’s actions, seen in the context of the Shiv Sena cadre’s long history of lumpen behaviour, would hardly surprise anyone. By not offering an unconditional, unqualified apology, the Sena has yet again betrayed its inability to function as a responsible party. For a party, aiming to return to power in Maharashtra after 15 years in the wilderness, the MPs actions might resonate with its militant core but could scare away ordinary law-abiding citizens. The Shiv Sena would do well to realise that the accumulated anti-incumbency against the three-term Congress-NCP government, rather than popular affinity towards its twin-espousal of Maharashtrian sub-nationalism and Hindutva, is facilitating its comeback.

The Congress which has energetically raised the issue, rightly, in Parliament must pause at this time to mull its own culpability, through inaction, on the Justice Srikrishna Commission report on the 1993 Mumbai riots that severely indicted Shiv Sena leaders. For the Muslim community, bereft of political representation in the ruling central dispensation, the recurring incidents — the murder of Pune techie Mohsin Sadiq Shaikh by a Hindu radical outfit for sporting a beard, the refusal by Parliament to discuss the Gaza violence, the presence of a Muzaffarnagar riots accused leader in the Modi Cabinet, to the latest incident — offer no comfort. The divergence between the secular ideal enshrined in the Constitution and the growing perceptions of injustice within the Muslim community merits the Centre’s attention.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has issued diktats on the code of conduct to be followed by his MPs but has maintained a studied silence on several troubling developments in the past two months having socio-political implications. His proactive stance on economic policy issues is welcome; but by not lending the stature of his office to comment on the burning social issues of the day, the signal it sends out is a State that can not be bothered by the fates of those vulnerable and in need of its support. Fifteen of the 18 Shiv Sena MPs in the Lok Sabha have criminal cases against their names and eight of them are accused of serious offences. Without political parties taking a stand against criminalisation, Parliament and India will continue to be shamed by such incidents.