India: Ambedkar disliked Muslims - BJP’s pitch to lure Dalits in Agra

The Indian Express

Ambedkar disliked Muslims: BJP’s pitch to lure Dalits in Agra
Sangh’s lessons in Dalit bastis aim to break alignment of Dalits, Muslims. Tweet This
Written by Ashutosh Bhardwaj | Agra | April 23, 2014

Shopkeepers in Chakki Pat, one of Agra’s biggest Dalit bastis. Ashutosh Bhardwaj. Shopkeepers in Chakki Pat, one of Agra’s biggest Dalit bastis. Ashutosh Bhardwaj.

“Dalits are the original inhabitants of India. Brahmins and other upper castes are Aryans who came from outside. Dr Ambedkar did not embrace Islam because he did not want Dalits to align with Muslims.”

This is the “history lesson” that the Sangh Parivar is secretly teaching the Dalits of Agra, a seat reserved for SCs, and considered the “capital of Dalits” because of their numerical dominance in the constituency.

Of the eight Lok Sabha seats in the belt known as Brij Pradesh, Agra is the only one that went to the BJP in 2009. Sitting MP Ram Shankar Katheria won narrowly, and has been an unpopular representative who finds himself on a sticky wicket as Agra goes to polls on Thursday.

Katheria is also a Dhanuk, an SC subcaste, while the overwhelming majority in Agra is Jatav, the caste Mayawati belongs to. Jatavs are natural BSP voters.

The over one lakh Muslim votes in the constituency have been traditionally divided among the SP, Congress and BSP. But following the Muzaffarnagar riots and the rise of Narendra Modi, Muslim votes appear to be consolidating behind the BSP.

Muslims say they will vote for the BSP’s Narayan Singh Suman because he alone can “stop” Modi. Even the BJP readily concedes that Suman is the strongest candidate here. Dalits and Muslims are neighbours almost everywhere in the constituency, and an alliance to vote together for the BSP is certain to hit the BJP.

It is in this background that the saffron camp has devised its two-pronged strategy: to “appropriate” Dr Ambedkar, and to employ his alleged “views” on Muslims to break the community’s alignment with Dalits.

“Jatav votes are crucial for us. They all go to BSP. So we have recently begun holding secret meetings in their bastis. We tell them that they and the Dravidians are the original inhabitants of India. The Aryans, Brahmins, etc. are outsiders who pushed them down the social ladder,” Rajnarain, the owner of a tent shop who is among a handful of Jatavs affiliated with the RSS-BJP, said.

Local leaders and party workers said the brain behind the meetings in Jatav bastis is Kesho Mehra, a former MLA from Agra who also used to be a BJP general secretary in undivided UP. Mehra’s association with the VHP-RSS is three decades old, and he is now a Sangh ideologue who has been assigned the task of “converting” Agra’s Dalits to the saffron fold.

“We tell them that Dr B R Ambedkar got the Bharat Ratna only during BJP rule. We also point out that had he embraced Islam, sabhi Daliton ko Mecca-Medina ki disha mein sar jhukaana padtaa (all Dalits would have had to bow in the direction of Mecca and Medina),” Rajnarain said.

Mehra said Ambedkar showed “great foresight” in choosing Buddhism over Islam.

“I am a great fan of Babasaheb Ambedkar. It was his great foresight that instead of adopting Islam, a foreign faith, he chose Buddhism, a religion that was born India,” Mehra said.

to help us personalise your reading experience.

He claimed that “Ambedkar repeatedly said that ‘if I adopted Islam with Dalits, my nationality would change, my cultural links would be severed, and India would be threatened to become an Islamic nation’.”

Mehra quoted from a book purportedly written by RSS ideologue Dattopant Thengadi, which apparently contains details of a meeting that Thengadi had with Ambedkar barely 45 days before the latter passed away in December 1956. According to Mehra, the book quotes Ambedkar as having told Thengadi, “I am about die. Had I not given a directive to my followers now, they would have joined Islam or Christianity after my death. So I am telling them to join Buddhism.”

These allegedly “true incidents” are now part of the BJP’s propaganda in Dalit bastis — used by Sangh workers to tell Dalits that they are “different” from Muslims, and advise them to stay away from Muslims, both socially and while voting on Thursday.

Several Dalit voters across Agra confirmed that these “lessons” were indeed being given, and estimated that at least 5-10 per cent of the Dalit vote could go to the BJP.

“Dalits and Muslims are voting together in Agra this time for haathi chhaap (BSP). But given the aggression with which the BJP is wooing our community, some voters will definitely switch sides. Some others might not actually vote for the BJP, but they will surely think before aligning with Muslims,” said Ram Charan and Ratan Kumar Bilawali, voters who have adjacent shops in Chakki Pat, one of Agra’s biggest Dalit bastis.