Book Review
Shades of Muslim Marginalization
Ram Puniyani
(Book Reviewed: Muslims in
Indian Cities: Trajectories of Marginalisation- Edited by Laurent Gayer and
Chritophe Jaffrelot, Harper Collins, Delhi 2012, Pages: 403, Price Rs 499)
The welfare of the minority
communities is the barometer of the health of a democracy. Going by that
dictum, this book shows the poor health of Indian democracy, as reflected by,
amongst other things, the marginalization of Muslim minorities. This edited
volume contains eleven essays well written essays, which deal with study of the
living spaces of Muslim community. The contributors to the volume have combined
the field study with analytic observations of the quality of lives of Muslim
community in these cities, some from the riot prone areas and other in the
cities from former Muslim states. This largest religious minority of India,
Muslims; have suffered a strange situation and have been subjected to communal
violence and economic discrimination; both. These twin processes has given rise
to the dynamics of politics from within the section of community which gives
more importance to the identity issues. The violence and discrimination are the
major factors leading to their marginality. This book is a unique contribution
to the study of Indian Muslims and shows the immaculate editorial imprint of
Chritophe Jafflerolt, who is a major authority on the politics of Hindu Right wing
along with Laurent Gayer. The editors have not only contributed to study of one
of the cities of the eleven discussed in the book, but their introduction to
the volume and conclusions tightly sum up the theme of the book, the
marginalization of Muslims from their earlier position of centrality.
The book revolves around the
ghettoes, slums and other forms of segregation, including self segregation of
the community during last six decades in particular. While the intensification
of this phenomenon has taken place during last three decades in particular
since the rise of Hindu nationalism, in conjunction with the compliant state.
This whole trajectory of the phenomenon has shaken the faith of the community
in the impartiality of the state. Muslims in India still bear the stigma of
being responsible for the vivisection of the country, which is nowhere near to
the truth. While making observations about the socio-economic and political condition
of the Muslims, the editors in particular base their analysis around the fact
that Muslims in India are no uniform community. Sachar committee and Rangnath
Mishra Commission have brought out the dismal condition of Muslims, their
discrimination in jobs and most of the aspects of economic life, in the arena
of representation in jobs and electoral politics. To blame the madrassas for
the plight of Muslims is also very much off the mark as only four percent of
Muslim children go to the madrassas. It is in this light the talk of
reservation for the Muslim community is gathering steam. Their representation in Lok Sabha, Parliament,
is constantly declining, today with 13.4 % (2001 data) of Muslims, in Lok Sabha
they are just 5.5%. The caste as factor of Muslim community is very much there,
but the caste factor in this community is overall eclipsed by the religious
identity as a minority. Comparatively Muslims are a more urbanized religious
group, and the fact is that urban Muslims are poorer that their rural
counterparts. It is in this backgrounds that the book sets out to compare the
place which the Muslim community occupies in the 11 Indian cities to observe
that this minority is declining, in a non linear way. To understand these case
studies included in the volume, authors survey the position of Muslims amongst
the local elite group. The case studies also look at the condition of Muslims
localities in Indian cities for testing the Ghettoisation thesis. The volume is
a unique mix of quantitative with qualitative approach, drawing from the
richness of each.
The case studies do show the
perception of three communities that ‘we are being pushed behind’. In Mumbai
the large section of Muslims are forced to live near the largest garbage dump.
One of the contributors Qudsiya Contractor argues that ‘state through its
violent spatial strategies and the Hindu right through its cultural populism
and communal politics, have played a crucial role’ in marginalization of this
minority. Editors in their study of riot
prone Ahmadabad, cull out a painful observation that in areas where there are
no Muslims in Ahmadabad are regarded as ‘good’ areas! This observation tells a direction
in which Indian democracy is being pushed over a period of time. In Ramganj in Jaipur, Gayatri Jaisingh Rathore
observes that ‘social interaction with other religious groups is limited and
the problems related to hygiene, education and unemployment abound’.
The editors quote Percival
Spear approvingly where he says that, being relegated to the second class citizenship;
Muslims have no future for them except their eventual absorption in Hindu mass.
The decline of Muslims is not uniform all over India; they have been more
resilient in Hindi belt, also known as cow belt. The process of ghettotisation
is also very diverse. In this bleak scenario a section of new Muslim middle
class is also emerging, around areas of meat export, leather goods, and Unani
medicine and also in the newer areas like agribusiness, IT, pharmaceuticals and
real estate. Connection with Gulf countries has also helped them in a major
way. The book gives an interesting insight into the process of cultural
occultation, which presents itself as ‘de-Islamized narrative’, which may be a
tactical one, a survival mechanism. At the same time there is also
re-Islamisation also there. How this dynamics of cultural occultation and re-islamization
will play itself, time alone will tell.
The totality of the process can be summed up in post partition fall and
identity politics, over determination by communal violence and political
obliteration and third is resilient cosmopolitanism. The totality of the
process gets manifested in the spatial process of mixed localities, Enclaves,
slums and Ghettoes. Mixed areas are replete with nostalgia and vestiges of
syncretic culture. Enclaves are due to interaction of a desire to share common
space with members of same community mostly after being pushed to ‘safe’ areas
after communal violence. Ghettoes are dynamic self segregation in search of
security.
The book comes are a very
incisive indictment of the present state of affairs of Indian state, which is heavily
tilted due to the communalization. The book gives not only a powerful incisive analysis
and observation of Muslim community, but also presents the sad plight through
which community is passing at the moment. The frightful prospect of
de-islamisation is very much in the store. While coming powerfully on these
major observations, it finally dismisses the need for reversal of the
phenomenon through political and social initiatives. Barring the prescription of Mohalla
committees, the book is silent on the immense possibilities of need for initiatives
in the field of education, need for campaigns for physical security, the dire
need to job provisions and economic alleviation, the subjective intervention to
bridge the divides along religious lines needed to be mentioned and elaborated
in the book dealing with the issue in such a profound way. Its content is a wakeup
call to reverse the ongoing negative processes and need to try to restore the
processes for communal amity and social peace, a pre requisite for development
of any nation and a community.
